Full Members Challenge Cup
- Finalists
- 1986
First Division (Old Format)
- Champions
- 1937,1968
- Runners-up
- 1904,1921,1977
Division One (New Format)
- Champions
- 2002
- Runners-up
- 2000
Second Division (Old Format)
- Champions
- 1899,1903,1910,1938,1947,1966
- Runners-up
- 1896,1951,1989
Division Two (New Format)
- Play-off winners
- 1999
FA Cup
- Winners
- 1903,1934,1956,1969
- Finalists
- 1926,1933,1955,1981
League Cup
- Winners
- 1970,1976
- Runners-up
- 1974
European Cup Winners' Cup
- Winners
- 1970